ITSM vs. ESM: Differences between IT and enterprise service management

Evaluating tools for employee service management can lead to a debate between ITSM vs. ESM as organizations look to optimize individual employee experiences. While both approaches aim to streamline service delivery and enhance team efficiency, they serve different scopes and purposes.

Understanding these distinctions is crucial to making an informed decision on a solution that aligns with your service delivery goals and employee satisfaction objectives.

The choice between IT and enterprise service management affects how your organization manages everything from help desk tickets to complex cross-departmental workflows. Read on to learn which solution can help your organization meet rising employee expectations and position your people for success.

More in this guide:

• What is IT service management (ITSM)?
• What is enterprise service management (ESM)?
• ITSM vs. ESM: Key similarities and differences
• How to choose between an ITSM and an ESM solution
• Let Zendesk expand your IT service repertoire

What is IT service management (ITSM)?

ITSM refers to the strategic approach businesses use to design, deliver, manage, and improve how their end users receive IT services. It aligns IT services with business needs while ensuring consistent, high-quality support for technology-related tickets. If the ITSM tool uses AI, it can reduce manual work like ticket triage to ensure tickets are delivered to the most qualified and available agents. Zendesk found that, conservatively, these tools help businesses save 45 seconds per ticket.

Overall, ITSM centers the IT department’s role in supporting different operations with features like:

• Incident management tools
• Problem management tools
• Request management tools
• Change management tools

There are typically established frameworks within ITSM, like Information Technology Infrastructure Library (ITIL), which provides best practices for IT service lifecycle management. These frameworks guide organizations through processes such as strategizing, operating, and continually improving their service. The ultimate goal of ITSM is to ensure IT services are reliable, cost-effective, and directly contribute to business growth.

What is enterprise service management (ESM)?

ESM extends service management principles beyond the IT department to encompass all service delivery capabilities across an organization. Whereas ITSM focuses on IT-specific services, an ESM-focused enterprise help desk takes a holistic approach that includes:

• Human resources management (HRM)

• Facilities management

• Finance

Basically, any department that provides internal services to employees is encompassed within ESM. This broader perspective recognizes that employees interact with multiple service providers throughout their workday, and each interaction contributes to their overall experience and productivity.

ITSM vs. ESM: Key similarities and differences

Comparing ITSM vs. ESM results reveals many similarities. Though ESM leverages the same foundational principles as ITSM, like standardized processes, an emphasis on self-service, and automated workflows, ESM applies those principles organization-wide.

Here’s where it gets interesting: these differences can complement each other rather than stand glaringly as opportunity costs of choosing one solution over the other. A robust ITSM can help strengthen ESM and better prepare employees to deliver top-tier customer service in their respective roles. And when customers and employees win, achieving service delivery excellence is easier than ever.

How to choose between an ITSM and an ESM solution

Choosing between ITSM and ESM solutions requires careful evaluation of your organization’s goals and resource capabilities. Follow these steps to determine the right solution for your specific needs.

Assess your service delivery maturity

Organizations with well-established, mature ITSM practices may find it easier to expand into ESM, while those still developing ITSM capabilities may benefit from an easy-to-implement IT-focused solution first.

Evaluate pain points and employee feedback

If complaints primarily center around your IT service desk, like slow response times or system outages, then an ITSM solution can address your immediate needs.

If employees also express frustration with experiences across HR, IT, and other departments, an ESM approach can provide the unified experience they desire. Above all, you should design the solution specifically for employees to unlock better productivity and avoid outdated, clunky experiences.

Consider change readiness

ESM implementations typically require more extensive training and coordination than an out-of-the-box ITSM solution like Zendesk, which is more realistic for many organizations’ current conditions.

These tools speed up time to value (TTV) by allowing organizations to scale to any department or complexity from day one, with no experienced developers needed.

Prioritize AI built to drive resolutions

The most advanced service management tools, like Zendesk, use AI to enhance efficiency and UX. It’s not only an ITSM trend—AI capabilities like predictive analytics and smart knowledge base recommendations significantly amplify the benefits of both ITSM and ESM approaches by:

• Improving response times

• Providing proactive insights

• Freeing up employee time for critical tasks (and reducing the burden on them with redundant manual work)

And with a tool like Zendesk, you get AI pre-trained on billions of real service interactions for accurate, efficient service that can fully automate up to 80 percent of interactions.

Define your long-term strategic vision

Organizations committed to a comprehensive overhaul might find that ESM aligns better with their goals, though ESM implementation takes longer. Those focused on specific IT service improvements can achieve a faster return on investment (ROI) through targeted investments that improve IT service delivery.

Ultimately, remember that this isn’t necessarily a permanent decision. Many successful organizations use a combination of ITSM and expanded ESM as their capabilities and organizational maturity develop.

DuPage County

DuPage County modernizes employee support and CX with Zendesk AI

“Zendesk's exceptional service at a competitive price provides DuPage County with significant value for our taxpayers."

Anthony McPhearson

Chief Information Officer

Read customer story

Transform your IT service experience with Zendesk’s scalable, AI-powered tools

Whether your business is ready to implement focused ITSM solutions or expand into comprehensive ESM capabilities, the foundation remains the same: delivering exceptional service experiences at scale that empower your employees and drive success.

Flexible, AI-powered IT help desk software from Zendesk grows with your ambitions. It offers supreme scalability and adaptability, so you can begin with IT-focused implementations and expand into enterprise-wide service delivery as your organization matures. With intuitive interfaces, powerful automation, and comprehensive reporting and analytics, Zendesk helps you create the seamless service experiences your employees deserve while providing you with the AI-driven insights you need to continuously improve.

Explore how Zendesk can transform your service management approach with a free trial today.